How do the issuers calculate yield for tax saving bonds?

by Manshu on October 30, 2010

in Fixed Deposits

Last week I took the L&T bond issue as an example to show how bond yields are calculated, and I thought I’d do a biggest post now to detail out some of the things said there so here goes.

There are a couple of tax saving bond recently issued by IDFC and L&T, so this is a good time to look at how the yield for these bonds are calculated, and some tools that will help you do so.

As you must have noticed the bond yields change with different plans, and I’m going to look at the IDFC issue with calculations to show how the yield on tax saving bonds are calculated.

Let me paste the details from the IDFC bonds here for quick reference because we will be using that as an example.

Investment Amount Tax Slab Series 1 Yield Series 2 Yield Series 3 Yield Series 4 Yield
5,000 30.9% 13.89 12.06 17.19 15.74
5,000 20.6% 11.57 10.52 13.41 12.57
5,000 10.30% 9.64 9.18 10.23 9.86
Rate of Interest ———– 8.00% p.a. N.A. 7.50% p.a. N.A.
Buyback Amount ———– 5,000 10,800 5,000 7,180
Time in years ———– 10 10 5 5

Let’s look at a couple of concepts before we deep dive in the process of calculation itself. These concepts are:

Effective Purchase price of a tax saving bond depends on your tax bracket

All bonds have a face value at which you will buy the bond and that is your cash outflow, however that’s not your effective purchase price in the case of tax saving infrastructure bonds. This is because these bonds reduce your taxable income, thereby reducing your tax outflow, and your effective purchase price is the face value of the bond minus the tax it saved you.

Effective Purchase Price = Face value of the bond – Tax saved by its purchase

Let’s look at this taking the IDFC bond as an example:

Face Value 5,000 5,000 5,000
Tax Bracket 10.30% 20.60% 30.90%
Tax Saved on Face Value 515 1,030 1,545
Effective Purchase Price 4,485 3,970 3,455

As you can see your effective purchase price goes down as your tax bracket increases, and this is one of the major reasons their yield table shows a higher yield with a higher tax bracket.

No matter which series you take – your yield will go up as your tax bracket increases because you save more on taxes.

So that explains one part of it, and now let’s look at why yield varies within the same tax bracket.

A lower time period will give you a higher yield

If you remember the IDFC bond issue had series with and without an option of a buy-back. The series with an option of buy-back would have meant that you need to hold these only for 5 years, whereas the other series meant you held on to the bonds for ten years.

The reason the bond yield varies in these two cases is that the absolute tax benefit you get remains the same in both the cases, but in one case it is spread out over only 5 years, whereas in the other case it is spread out over 10 years. The tax you save will be the same whether you invest in the buyback option or not, and since the interest rate is much lesser than the tax savings – a longer time period lowers the yield.

So in this case if you compare Series 1 and 3 or Series 2 and 4 – everything is the same except the buyback period and that’s causing the difference in yield.

How to calculate bond yield when no interests are paid?

These series differ by two factors – buyback option, and payment of interest.

We looked at the buyback option and how it affects bond yield earlier, and now let’s look at payment of interest. One series pays out interest annually, whereas the other series doesn’t pay out any interest annually, but rather pays a lump-sum at the end of the time period.

Let’s first look at the yield for the series that pays a lump-sum.

You already know what your effective purchase price is, and you also know what you will get at the end of the time period, so all you need to do is to plug in these numbers in the Compounded Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) Calculator and see what the yield is.

Conceptually you are saying that if I start out with Rs. 3,455 (30.9% tax rate) then what is the rate of interest at which I should invest this sum, and also the interest earned every year, so that I reach at the amount at the end – Rs. 7,180 (series 4 example).

Here is how that table looks like.

Investment Amount Tax Slab Effective Purchase Price Series 2 Yield

(CAGR)

Series 4 Yield

(CAGR)

5,000 30.9% 3,455 12.06 15.74
5,000 20.6% 3,970 10.52 12.57
5,000 10.30% 4,485 9.18 9.86
Buyback Amount ———– ——- 10,800 7,180
Time in years ———– ——- 10 5

The post about CAGR also details how it is calculated, so you can read more there.

In future to calculate any bond yield where there are no annual interest payments look for these elements:

  • Face Value
  • Tax Bracket
  • Effective purchase price
  • Time in years
  • Buyback amount

Then use effective purchase rate, time and buyback amount in the CAGR calculator to find out the yield.

How to calculate bond yield when interest is paid yearly?

When the interest is paid out yearly – you need to use a formula called Yield To Maturity (YTM) and calculate the bond’s yield. There is a nice little calculator present on this site that you can use to see how this works out. Use Series 1 and 3 and you will get a table such as the one below.

Investment Amount Tax Slab Effective Purchase Price Series 1 Yield

(YTM)

Series 3 Yield

(YTM)

5,000 30.9% 3,455 13.89 17.19
5,000 20.6% 3,970 11.57 13.41
5,000 10.30% 4,485 9.64 10.23
Buyback Amount ———– ——- 5,000 5,000
Time in years ———– ——- 10 5
Coupon Rate 8.00% 7.50%

If you input 3,455 in Current Market Price, 5,000 in Par Value, 8.00% in coupon rate, and 10 years – you will get your yield.

This formula assumes that whatever interest payments you received were re-invested at the coupon rate, and then takes the market value of the bond to calculate your yield.

In our example, this formula will say that you invested Rs. 3,455 initially, then get Rs. 400 at the end of every year which you will continue to re-invest at 8% and reap the benefit of compounding. Now this is an assumption so if you don’t actually end up investing your interest payment every year your yield will be reduced.

Factors not looked at while calculating yield on tax saving bonds

One obvious factor is the yield doesn’t take into account the taxes that you will end up paying on interest received. Other factor is that this formula doesn’t take into account any transaction costs that you incur.

I have another post lined up next week which looks at the limitations of the way these yields are being calculated in which I will cover some things that are not part of the way the yields are calculated by the issuer.

Conclusion

When you see a yield on a table – you might say higher is better, but then you need to keep in mind that in some cases to get the highest yield you will have to re-invest the interest payment yourself also.

Then there is the issue of time period also, would you much rather have your money back in 5 years or you are fine with keeping the money invested for 10 years since it is a relatively small amount.

Then of course, if you pay tax on that interest your yield goes down automatically by the amount of your tax paid.

I covered a fairly big area here, so if you feel that I got something incorrect, or something could be explained better please feel free to leave a comment, and I’ll try to answer it, or correct it as the case may be.

{ 18 comments… read them below or add one }

Anshul November 10, 2010 at 8:11 pm

Excellent Post ….Thanks for writing in simple and easy to understand way..Keep up the good work !!

Reply

Manshu November 11, 2010 at 11:40 am

Thanks Anshul!

Reply

Shitalkumar December 30, 2010 at 2:25 am

Very neatly explained article.Thanks for the detailed information.

Reply

Manshu December 30, 2010 at 3:41 am

Thanks Shital.

Reply

Basant Chandran January 21, 2011 at 5:24 am

This is a neat post… clear and simple. Good job.

Reply

Manshu January 21, 2011 at 10:47 am

Thanks Basant.

Reply

incometaxguy January 22, 2011 at 9:13 am

Short and sweet! Great inforrmation

Reply

Manshu January 23, 2011 at 1:28 am

Thanks

Reply

Girish February 3, 2011 at 8:37 am

The link “nice little calculator present on this site” doesn’t seem to be working. May be you can explain what would be found at the link in your post.

Reply

Manshu February 3, 2011 at 10:31 am

It does work. It is a bond yield calculator at moneychimp.com

Try it again – it should work.

Reply

Girish February 3, 2011 at 11:36 pm

Yeah, It works now. Yesterday night when I was trying to access the link the browser came back with some thing like could not find resource.

Reply

Manshu February 4, 2011 at 11:23 pm

Their site might be down at that time….

Reply

Dr Abhay Pathak February 22, 2011 at 8:21 pm

Thanks for detailed note on it. Why you did not factor in the income tax on tax income. I mean if i am right if i do as follows
Effective PP : 1000- 206= 794
Net Proceeds after 5 yrs = 1436 – 89.8= 1346
1346 / 794 = 1.695

Reply

Manshu February 23, 2011 at 2:21 pm

Normally when one talks about returns they don’t talk about the tax paid, so for instance when someone says equities return 12% or say that Canara Bank gives out 9.5% for 8 years on their FD – they are not thinking about income tax at that point in time.

However, I have done another post about the limitation on the way these bond yields are calculated and I take up the issue there.

Reply

Muthu Krishnan V November 27, 2011 at 11:30 am

I have a query regarding taxation. In the case of annual interest pay-out, the interest will be added to the income and taxed at respective tax-slab.

but in the case of cumulative pay-out say buy-back after 5 years, will it be treated as LTCG and taxed at 10% without indexation and 20% with indexation? If so, this will be more beneficial for 30% tax slab people. Kindly clarify.

Reply

Manshu November 27, 2011 at 8:39 pm

It won’t be treated as capital gains but treated the same way as interest income.

Reply

Aditya T December 10, 2011 at 6:01 pm

Hi Manshu,

Your explanation is clear and simple. Excellent work.

Reply

Manshu December 11, 2011 at 5:11 am

Great to hear that – thanks!

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: